AppealNow.com – Reversing the Charges
High Court authority on mandatory PCN particulars

Moses v Barnet: The PCN Two-Date Requirement

R (London Borough of Barnet) v The Parking Adjudicator [2006] EWHC 2357 (Admin); [2007] RTR 14 is the High Court judgment confirming that the PCN then governed by section 66 of the Road Traffic Act 1991 required two distinct dates: the date of contravention and the date of notice.

What the High Court Decided

Barrie Segal represented the motorist, Hugh Moses, at the adjudication and attended the High Court hearing. Barnet argued that its PCNs substantially complied even though the date of notice was not separately stated.

Mr Justice Jackson rejected that argument. He held that the notice date was required and explained why the date of contravention and date of notice are not necessarily the same. Certainty about the notice date matters because statutory payment periods are calculated by reference to it.

The central principle

The required notice date and the date of the alleged contravention are separate statutory particulars. Where the regulations also require the time of contravention, that must be stated as well.

The 2007 Regulations Carried the Requirement Forward

The Schedule to the Civil Enforcement of Parking Contraventions (England) General Regulations 2007 expressly required a regulation 9 PCN to state the date on which the notice is served and the date and the time at which the alleged contravention occurred.

For a regulation 10 postal PCN, the regulations required the date of the notice, which had to be the date on which it was posted, together with the date and time of the contravention.

The 2022 Regulations Continue the Same Core Requirement

Schedule 2 to the Civil Enforcement of Road Traffic Contraventions (Approved Devices, Charging Guidelines and General Provisions) (England) Regulations 2022 defines the “regulatory matters” to include the date on and the time at which the alleged contravention occurred.

A regulation 9 PCN must separately include the date on which the notice is served. A regulation 10 postal PCN must separately include the date of the notice, which must be the date on which it is posted.

Why Moses v Barnet Still Matters

The judgment has not been overturned. Its original statutory setting was the Road Traffic Act 1991, which has since been superseded, so a modern challenge must identify the legislation that governs the modern notice. But the two-date requirement at the heart of the case was expressly reproduced in the successor 2007 and 2022 regulatory schemes.

The broader reasoning also remains important: a PCN is a statutory document, and mandatory statutory particulars cannot simply be treated as optional because an authority says no prejudice was caused.

What to Check on a Modern PCN

  • Is the required date of notice/service stated?
  • Is the date of the alleged contravention stated?
  • Is the time of the alleged contravention stated?
  • For a regulation 10 postal PCN, is the notice date the posting date?
  • Are the other mandatory particulars required for that type of notice present?